|
    Theme
    National Verified Story

    Tougher than the crowd

    Sajal Ali•November 22, 2026• 13 min read
    Text Size
    Tougher than the crowd
    National CoverageAman-e-Pakistan Digital Desk
    Key Story Executive Summary
    Quick Read

    “Back to Tribune. HomeT-Magazine. Tougher than the crowdT-Magazine. Next Story. Tougher than the crowd. From open mics to sold-out shows, Pakistan's comedians are finding new audiences but still struggling to ma…”

    Back to Tribune. HomeT-Magazine. Tougher than the crowdT-Magazine. Next Story. Tougher than the crowd. From open mics to sold-out shows, Pakistan's comedians are finding new audiences but still struggling to make a living. By. Nabil Tahir|Design by: Anusha NasirfacebooktwitterwhatsuplinkdedemailPUBLISHED

    November 22, 2026Calling someone an aunty in Pakistan is usually considered a harmless way of addressing an older woman. But for stand-up comedian Obaid Ur Rehman, it nearly resulted in a shoe being thrown at him during a performance in Karachi.

    Rehman, aka Obi Outloud, was doing crowd work at Habitt City, interacting with people seated in the audience, when he addressed a woman as “aunty”. The woman did not appreciate it., she became angry, took off her shoe and appeared ready to throw it at him.

    Key Story Takeaway

    "Stay connected with Aman-e-Pakistan for ongoing live reporting and verified investigative updates."

    An organiser stepped in and tried to remove her from the show, but Rehman asked him to let her stay. Rehman recalls. “I her be.

    I turned the whole situation into jokes, and eventually even she was laughing.”There were around 150 people in the room that evening, and what could have become an uncomfortable confrontation ended up providing some of the biggest laughs of the show. Such moments are part of what makes live stand-up comedy different from watching a comedian on a phone screen.

    A joke can work with one audience and fall flat with another. Sometimes the audience becomes part of the performance, leaving the comedian to respond without knowing what might happen next. For Rehman, who began performing stand-up in 2024, dealing with such situations has become part of learning the craft.

    He is among a growing number of performers trying to establish themselves in Pakistan's developing stand-up scene, as comedy nights, open mics and ticketed shows begin attracting audiences beyond their traditional venues. Finding the funny.

    Rehman had never seriously considered becoming a stand-up comedian until his university friends encouraged him to give it a try. It was the middle of 2024, and they had been watching Indian stand-up comedians online.

    They thought Rehman, who had spent years participating in debating societies and public-speaking competitions, might be good at it. He began searching for places in Karachi where he could perform and eventually came across Natalia Gul's The Jungle PK on Instagram.

    Before signing up himself, he attended a couple of shows to see how things worked. His first performance was at Harley in Defence, where he was given 10 minutes in front of an audience of just 12 people.

    Public speaking was his forte throughout school, college and university, so Rehman had expected the experience to be relatively straightforward. It wasn't. “I used to debate throughout school, college and university, so I thought there wouldn't be much pressure,” he recalls.

    “But stand-up is very different from debating. You might have the confidence to speak, but here you expect people to laugh.”The audience responded well enough to encourage him to continue, and he began performing more regularly.

    For comedians who started earlier, finding somewhere to perform was often just as difficult as finding an audience. Faiza Saleem, who began creating comedy content online in 2014 and subsequently established the all-women improv troupe Khawatoons, says Pakistan's comedy scene has changed considerably, although much of that progress has been concentrated on digital platforms.

    “When it comes to content creation, there's a lot more appreciation. It's become normal to have an account on Instagram or Facebook and create content,” she says. But live comedy, particularly improv, has struggled to keep pace., suitable performance venues remain limited, and many people still do not understand the difference between improv and stand-up.

    The shortage of opportunities was especially apparent when she began putting Khawatoons together. Faiza recalls approaching women individually, sometimes having to persuade them to consider performing comedy on stage. The troupe has now completed a decade, with several members going on to perform independently.

    “A lot of doors have been opened for some women. I wouldn't say it for all women, because there are very few opportunities for women in general to do comedy,” she says. While performers continue to face difficulties finding suitable spaces, comedy is reaching audiences in parts of Karachi where such events were previously uncommon.

    Natalia, who runs The Jungle PK, says shows were once largely concentrated in Defence and Clifton. Her organisation has since taken performances to Gulshan-e-Iqbal, Gulistan-e-Jauhar and Nazimabad, where she says the response has been encouraging.

    “When we do it there, the response is better because people are thirsty for such entertainment,” she says. For 36-year-old Arsalan Ahmed, the introduction to live comedy came through social media. He had been watching videos of Akbar Chaudry and Shehzad Ghias during the Covid years but did not realise that comedy shows were taking place regularly in Karachi.

    A friend eventually invited him to a performance at a small café in DHA.The venue was packed, and Ahmed enjoyed the evening enough to begin attending other shows. He now goes once or twice a month, finding most events through Instagram or recommendations from friends.

    What began as an occasional outing has become another option for spending an evening in the city. Beyond the punchline. For an audience member, a stand-up performance may appear to be a comedian simply talking about everyday experiences and making people laugh.

    But even a short set can take weeks of writing, experimenting and performing before the jokes begin to work consistently. For Rehman, ideas often come from conversations with friends or things he notices while travelling around Karachi.

    He makes notes whenever something strikes him as funny, works on the material at home and then tries it in front of an audience. He recalls developing a joke during a period of heightened tensions between Pakistan and India, when he heard a report about an Indian ship supposedly heading towards Karachi.

    Driving along University Road, he noticed the potholes and began wondering why anyone would want to capture a city with roads in such poor condition. He turned the observation into a joke, which he says later attracted between eight and 10 million views online.

    But not every joke gets that kind of response, and comedians need somewhere to find out what works before putting together a longer performance. Natalia says open mics provide that opportunity for both newcomers and experienced comedians.

    Some performers write their material from beginning to end, while others develop an idea through conversations and repeated performances. The process can take considerable time, particularly when someone is working towards a full-length show. “You come to your open mics and test your material.

    And the specials that you see on You. Tube or Netflix, they are made only after testing on open mics,” Natalia explains. The problem, she says, is that Pakistan has relatively few regular spaces where performers can test new material.

    Establishing weekly open mics through The Jungle PK was partly a response to that shortage, as she needed somewhere to work on her own jokes. Even after preparing their material, comedians cannot always predict how an audience will respond.

    Ahmed, who attends stand-up shows regularly, says some of the funniest moments come from interactions that nobody could have planned. At one performance at Rangoonwala Community Centre, he recalls a comedian approaching a serious-looking man seated with his nephew.

    The comedian began joking about why the nephew had brought his uncle to a show featuring adult humour. Instead of taking offence, the older man started revealing embarrassing details about his nephew, giving the comedian more material to work with.

    Such exchanges are part of what Ahmed enjoys about live performances. Unlike the short clips circulating on social media, audiences get to watch comedians respond to situations as they happen, including when their prepared jokes fail.

    “When you're watching a reel, it's already been edited. You're watching the part that got the most laughs,” he says. “But when you're sitting there, you see everything, including jokes that don't work.”There is also the question of what comedians can say, particularly when their material moves beyond the room where it was originally performed.

    Faiza says female comedians continue to face expectations and restrictions that influence what they perform publicly. Although audiences have become more accepting of different styles of humour, she believes performers must still consider how their jokes might be received outside the venue.

    “Social media trolling is still a thing and social media backlash is still a thing. So honestly, even after 10 years, we are still very careful,” she says. Faiza points out that Khawatoons does not generally publish its improv performances online, despite having performed for years.

    Natalia has similar reservations about sharing live material. She recalls facing criticism after a joke intended to highlight an issue affecting the Baloch community was interpreted by some viewers as disparaging. In her view, a joke delivered during a full performance can be understood differently when an isolated clip circulates online.

    “When you're in a show, you're on a journey with us from start to finish. You understand the context, you understand the comedian's personality,” she says. “When you watch a one-second clip, you can't judge it properly.”For comedians, keeping material offline can also be a practical decision.

    A joke that has already been watched thousands of times may no longer get the same reaction when performed live. Rehman experienced this while building his online following, often choosing to upload jokes rather than save them for his first stand-up special.

    “I had this dilemma: do I save it for my special or do I post it? Usually, I used to post it,” he says. It is a decision that reflects the unusual position of emerging comedians in Pakistan.

    They need people to discover their work online, but they also need fresh material to give those same people a reason to buy tickets and watch them perform. The business of laughter. For comedians trying to establish themselves in Pakistan, getting an audience to laugh is only part of the challenge.

    Getting enough people to buy tickets, finding a suitable venue and covering the cost of organising a show can be just as difficult. Natalia, who has been running comedy shows for seven years, says the financial returns are often modest, particularly when performances depend entirely on ticket sales.

    A show with 50 people paying Rs 1,000 or Rs 1,500 each may generate between Rs 50,000 and Rs 75,000, but that amount has to cover the venue, marketing and payments to performers. “You have to pay for the venue, you have to set a marketing budget, and you also have to pay for the comics.

    So if you have a ticket for Rs 1,000 or Rs 1,500, and you have a crowd of 50, what will you get from it?” she asks. Natalia says corporate events and sponsored performances offer better financial opportunities, but regular sponsorship remains difficult to secure.

    Much of The Jungle PK's work has been sustained by her interest in developing the scene rather than expectations of substantial profits. Having built an audience over several years, she says the shows now generally break even or make a profit, although that does not necessarily translate into a steady income for individual comedians.

    For newer performers, the financial uncertainty begins even before they have enough material for a full-length show. Rehman says the biggest concern ahead of his first stand-up special was not whether he could make people laugh, but whether they would buy tickets in the first place.

    “I wasn't worried about whether I would be able to make people laugh. I was worried about whether I could sell tickets,” he recalls. The show eventually sold out a day before the performance.

    Rehman believes his online presence played an important role in convincing people to attend, particularly in a city where comedy performances do not yet have the established circuit that allows audiences to turn up at a familiar venue every week. That connection between social media and live entertainment is also apparent in how audiences discover shows.

    For Ahmed, who generally pays between Rs 1,000 and Rs 2,500 to attend a show, ticket prices are not necessarily the problem. Larger performances, he says, can cost as much as Rs 4,000, but he considers the expense reasonable compared with other entertainment options in Karachi.

    What bothers him more is when the facilities fail to justify the price. He considers the prices reasonable compared with other ways of spending an evening in Karachi, but says the facilities do not always justify the expense.

    At some shows, poor sound or uncomfortable seating arrangements have affected his experience. “I don't mind paying Rs 2,000 or even more if the show is good and I can sit comfortably,” Ahmed says. While live comedians continue to struggle with limited resources, comedy creators have gained considerably more visibility through digital platforms.

    That recognition was reflected at the inaugural Pakistan Influencer Awards 2026, held in Karachi in this month, where Ali Abdullah won Comedy Creator of the Year. The nominees included Akbar Chaudry, Ammar Zaidi, Romaisa Khan and Ducky Bhen.

    Faiza, who hosted the awards, believes the recognition reflects how far digital content creation has progressed as a profession. “I've been doing this for so many years, but never have content creators been recognised on this scale,” she says.

    However, Faiza points out that the opportunities available to digital creators are not necessarily available to those performing stand-up and improv. While she believes stand-up has the potential to become a sustainable profession, she is less optimistic about improv, which still struggles with limited performance spaces and relatively little public understanding.

    “I wish improv could become a full-time career for people. But at the moment, it is not,” she says. For Natalia, comedians who want to earn a living may need to explore opportunities beyond performing stand-up alone, including digital content, hosting and corporate events.

    Rehman, meanwhile, believes the industry is still too young for performers to judge its financial potential. “We don't know how viable it is because this is not an industry that's already stable. We are actually carving our path ourselves,” he says.

    For now, performers are finding different ways to make that path work, whether through regular open mics, social media audiences or ticketed performances. The interest in live comedy is there, but developing a reliable business around it remains a challenge.

    When the laughter ends. For Arsalan, comedy shows have become an alternative to the usual weekend plans in Karachi, where meeting friends often means finding another restaurant to visit. “In Karachi, whenever you make a plan with friends, the first question is usually where to eat.

    And after a while, you get tired of doing the same thing,” he says. Not every performance he has attended has been enjoyable. Some comedians have struggled to get a laugh, while others have relied too heavily on vulgar jokes.

    There have also been occasions when poor arrangements have affected the experience. Still, he continues to attend the gigs, sometimes choosing smaller open mics where he has no idea who will be performing. “I wouldn't say every show is worth the money.

    I've attended a few average ones too,” he says. “But generally, I enjoy going and would rather spend on a comedy show occasionally than go to another restaurant just for the sake of going out.”Pages.

    Pakistan. Business. World.

    Opinion. Life & Style. Sports.

    Blogs. Videos. Our Sites.

    Express News. Urdu E-Paper. English E-Paper.

    Sindhi E-Paper. Cricket Pakistan. Express Live.

    Campus Guru. Express Entertainment. Food Tribune.

    About Us. Contact Us. Online Advertising.

    Privacy Policy. Copyright. Fuel Prices Pakistan.

    Gold Prices Pakistan. Prayer Timing Pakistan. Weather Forecast Pakistanfollow us

    S

    Written by Sajal Ali

    Aman-e-Pakistan Senior Journalist & Bureau Reporter

    Fact Checked & Verified

    Continue Reading: More in National

    Swipe or click arrows to explore National desk coverage

    Senior journalist and human rights activist Hussain Naqi passes away at 88National

    Senior journalist and human rights activist Hussain Naqi passes away at 88

    Read Story
    Geo Headlines 8AM | 22 November 2026National

    Geo Headlines 8AM | 22 November 2026

    Read Story
    The things that outlive usNational

    The things that outlive us

    Read Story
    A breath of toxic airNational

    A breath of toxic air

    Read Story
    The things we choose not to seeNational

    The things we choose not to see

    Read Story
    Lazio maintain Serie A leadNational

    Lazio maintain Serie A lead

    Read Story